Here is my breakdown of this big box store:
Pros - Coupons! Just about every week it seems I receive coupons either through the official sales mailer, occasional mail flyers, online, and email. If you're going to Joann's without a coupon, then you obviously have more cash that should be spent elsewhere. I particularly enjoy the total purchase percentage off coupons, even the measly 10% or 20% off ones.
Con - Not too long ago the coupons were applicable towards magazines. And even absent that, they would have the 10% off mags sale on occasion. Now I never see one. Do you know how expensive magazines are??? Well, I do, and I was fine with the 10% off arrangement even if it was cheaper to sign up for a subscription.
Pro - You can sometimes score a good deal on a piece of nice fabric. With said coupon.
Con - Their signature quilting fabrics are cheap, worthless crap. The weight is akin to bastiste or voile, not a cotton weight that I feel would withstand any piecing or quilting that I do. Sure, they have their premium line, but the selection is sparse. As for fashion fabric, I'm not terribly impressed.
Pro - Occasionally, you get an awesome sale, and you have to lay down the clams.
Con - It doesn't matter whether I'm buying a little or a lot, once I approach the registers, a long line appears, and there's goes a quick trip. Plus, it becomes more and more difficult to bat off my three year old's pleas for gummis and lollipops.
Major con - Invariably, I am overcharged for something. This commonly happens when quilting or knitting books are on sale, but apparently only specially labeled ones are discounted.
Pro - You can pick up patterns for almost nothing. (I still remember paying full price for patterns, but, back then, it was around $5.)
Con - I'm buying less patterns from the big 4 and paying more attention to independent designers and companies. (Still though, there are a lot of good patterns by the major pattern companies.)
My husband may not believe this, but I have not been to Joann's in a few months, and, the last time I was inside, my purchase was minimal. Right now, I hardly get excited to open the mailer. If I need fashion fabric, I head over to a Stone Mountain and Daughter in Oakland. I especially love their knits, and I'm sure to find the right notion or tool that isn't completely worthless after a few uses. They have quilting fabrics, too, but, for that, I check out the Cotton Patch in Lafayette and my local Beverly's. My yarn purchases are in a bit of a lull, largely because I have a huge stash. Even so, I hit up the local yarn shops and Beverly's.
Maybe it's because I live in the Bay Area and there are more choices. Or I'm getting older. Stingier. You'd probably laugh if I proclaimed to have selective, refined taste. I would, too, because I don't.
The likely answer? At base, I no longer have the time, tolerance, or energy for that place. Every time I decide to give it one more try, I end up feeling frustrated and even more discouraged. Does anyone have similar thoughts? It'd be nice to know that I'm not the only one.